Join MultiplyOpen a Free ShopSign InHelp
MultiplyLogo
SEARCH

Blog from the Kootenays on Life, the Universe and Everything

Blog EntryDec 8, '07 9:16 PM
for everyone


Hark the Herald Angels! Bring on the Nativity scenes! Send in the Carols!

In the name of the Mother, the Daughter, and the Holy Crone.

 

What I mean by the label is: Nature is the connection I use to commune with the Great Mystery. I am happy to call it The Great Mystery, the Tao,  and let it go at that.

 

Mystics of all religions get along just fine. As a Christian theologian said (sorry, forgot his name): “God is a metaphor for God.” Amen.

 

AND (and, not but) I was raised as a good little Christian girl. Part of me will always resonate to those particular rituals. Rituals feed the soul. I love Christmas Carols. The real kind: Herald Angels, Oh Night Divine, Once in Royal David’s City, and so on. They are simply too beautiful to be reserved solely for Christian believers.

I’ll do another post sometime about how they became part of my Dutch childhood.

 

We used to hear carols over the airwaves in the Advent season. When did that change? As early as 1992 I wrote a letter to CBC radio complaining about their lack.

 

What went wrong? Perhaps it is this: Minorities and those who champion them need to make a clear distinction between wrongful discrimination and the simple inconvenience of being a minority. That seems to get mixed up.

 

When someone is denied schooling, employment or housing strictly on the basis of ethnic identity, skin colour, religion, gender, etc, that is wrongful discrimination. Most people of goodwill agree that everyone deserves an equal chance at the goodies.

 

But when a Muslim, Hindu or atheist has to lay eyes on a plastic baby Jesus in the mall, that is merely an inconvenience. It is NOT religious persecution or discrimination. If you want to feel real discrimination, try being a Bahai in Iran or a Christian or avowed Atheist in Saudi Arabia.

 

I am all in favor of a strict separation between church and state. But I always thought that that simply meant that the state would refrain from dictation in matters of personal religion.

 

In my opinion public schools should indeed be secular. That doesn’t mean anti-religious, just neutral. If you want your child to be indoctrinated in your personal faith, take care of it at home or send her to private school.

In my grandson’s school in Greater Vancouver, B.C. Christian kids and those of European extraction are as much a minority as everyone else.

In that context it makes total sense to change the traditional Christmas Pageant into a bland midwinter celebration.

 

But when did we get all paranoid about displays of religious symbols in public space?

Are our own convictions so pathetically insecure that we cannot handle

being exposed to another view?  What does that have to do with freedom?

 

True beauty has been replaced with insipid winter songs that reek of plastic and the Mall. That disgusting Reindeer story deserves a rant all on its own.

 

Please, bring back the carols.  They feed the soul on a deep level.

And when the time comes for Diwali, Hanukkah, Eid, or other celebrations, let’s hear the songs that go with those.

 

Let’s celebrate them all, instead of none!

 


 


8 Comments
idesofmarch wrote on Dec 8, '07, edited on Dec 8, '07
"But when did we get all paranoid about displays of religious symbols in public space?"

One of the pillars of Marxism is the abolition of religion. In the capitalist west, they don't have power yet so they gradually chip away at religious expression bit by bit. It was the Soviets behind the attempted assassination of the Pope in 1981 for example.

redrobin11 wrote on Dec 8, '07
I feel closest to creation when i am in the woods being quiet and listening to nature. No music, bibles, or preachy people regardless of what religion they are 'pushing'. Sometimes it [religion of any type] just gets way too intense.
idesofmarch wrote on Dec 8, '07
That's probably why so many spiritual journeys in the bible such as Moses take place in the solitude of the desert.
sattva2 wrote on Dec 9, '07
agree with redrobin11 - I believe that Religion divides people, but a shared Belief in something (Spirituality) brings people together ! It is unfortunate that religious Fanatics always show the worst side of their faith !
ienvan wrote on Dec 9, '07
Robin, Annette: That's exactly what I meant choosing that label. George, I enjoy your wit and intellect, but are you for real? People truly still believe that commies are trying to take over the world?? Personally, I find ANY ideology scary.
ienvan wrote on Dec 9, '07
That's probably why so many spiritual journeys in the bible such as Moses take place in the solitude of the desert.
Yes, spiritual journeys usually involve going into Nature. I sincerely believe that
part of the malaise of young people today comes from living so far from Her.
I would love to see more gardening as part of the school curriculum.
faestone wrote on Dec 18, '10
"Let’s celebrate them all, instead of none!"

INDEED!!!

Love this rant. It's so well written and expresses what I think an awful lot of folks feel. I too am pagan, but raised Christian..and yes, there are songs that still stir me.. the music is so beautiful.

Ever feel the energy raised by a Gospel Choir?? WOW!! Now THAT'S magic!!

I agree with you absolutely... Let's celebrate them all... acknowledge and celebrate our differences together.
kittybriton wrote on Dec 6, '11
ienvan said
Please, bring back the carols. They feed the soul on a deep level.
There are very few Christmas carols that I cannot hear without being moved profoundly. It's not just music, it's blowing on the embers of hope.
Add a Comment